Pacquiao vs Marquez: 3rd installment generates mixed reactions


MANILA, Philippines—Pound-for-pound king Manny Pacquiao’s conquest of his greatest nemesis Juan Manuel Marquez Saturday night (Sunday in Manila) was not met with jubilance that usually follows his victories.

The frenzied crowd, mostly Mexicans, at the sold-out MGM Grand Garden Arena in Las Vegas wasted no time in showing great displeasure at the result. While in a rare sighting, most fans, across the globe here in Manila, filed out of the venues of the viewing parties—puzzled.

It wasn’t that they were not in a celebratory mood once ring announcer Michael Buffer uttered the words “and still the WBO Welterweight champion of the world.” It was just that the celebration of the majority decision did not last long.

It was more of a sigh of relief than a convincing roar of delight—that was the collective reaction of the spectators at the Hard Rock Cafe in a mall in Makati.

Virgilio Cruz, 58, who watched at Hard Rock with his family, told his wife shortly after the fight, “He [Pacquiao] should have lost today.”

The same reaction from fans all over the world reverberated on Twitter: Pacquiao might have not been the convincing winner of this greatly hyped third clash.

“I’m a Pacquiao fan, but I saw a Mexican win tonight,” said Juan Vidal on his Twitter account (@kaizerdouken).

“(I believe) Marquez won the fight. The best Pacman could have gotten was a draw,” echoed Berwin Yambao (@iamwin47).

“Manny (Pacquiao) won, but he didn’t prove he’s the winner of the trilogy,” said Emerson Kim (@emersonkim).

Here’s the thing—the third fight was supposed to settle the score between the two—but instead, it just raised more questions than answers as to who owns this epic trilogy.

Even some boxing experts and foreign writers, who have been keeping tabs on Pacquiao in the past decade, believed the decision should have went in Marquez’s favor.

“I scored it 116-112 for Marquez. Highway robbery,” said Sports Illustrated‘s NBA and Boxing writer Chris Mannix on his Twitter account (@chrismannixSI). “Competitive fight. I thought wrong decision.”

ESPN’s Chris Broussard, who also covers the NBA, thought it should have been a draw.

“Great fight. Tough to call. I’d say a draw or Marquez,” Broussard posted on @Chris_Broussard. “I don’t think Manny thinks he won, based on his reaction…bad decision…”

The result was debatable—but the truth was, it wasn’t one of Pacquiao’s best performances. In all of his stellar career, Marquez was probably that one fighter who gave him all he could handle—all three times they met.

“I really think if these guys fought ten more times, every round would be close. They are perfect foes,” added Mannix.

“These boxers are made for each other,” said ESPN’s Dan Rafael on his Twitter (@danrafaelESPN).

Some fans, though, think the victory was some sort of coincidental “payback” for the first fight which ended in a draw in 2004. Pacquiao should have claimed the victory if the judges had scored the first round, where Pacquiao floored Marquez thrice, correctly.

“Let me just say Pacquiao was cheated a victory in their 1st fight and got the same break now,” shared Cesar Delos Reyes (Tito Ces).

“Come to think of it, Manny [Pacquiao] got robbed in first fight,” said Inquirer’s football reporter Cedelf Tupas (@cedelfpt).

But maybe the fans, through half of the past decade, got used to Pacquiao pulverizing his opponents that anything short of a knockout was a fluke.

“For fight fans, Pacquiao is in the same boat as (Anderson) Silva and GSP [George St-Pierre]. If they don’t destroy their opponents, it’s not enough,” said TV analyst and former PBA player Jason Webb (@Jason_Webb_Phil).

“Manny Pacquiao has spoiled all of you. Just because he didn’t demolish him, he didn’t win?” asked Chris Ross (@cmross6) of the Meralco Bolts in the Philippine Basketball Association.

But even Marquez, who has never been able to floor Pacquiao in all of the 36 rounds they battled in the ring, could have used a knockdown to sway the judges.

“In order for him to win, he should have KO’d Manny. But he did not. So Manny [is] still the champ!” exclaimed Girl Pacino (@girl_pacino).

And just like the fans from all over the world whose opinions are clashing, Pacquiao and Marquez themselves, in their three fights, still will never concede on who truly won.

Pacquiao believed he “won the fight,” while Marquez remained puzzled on “what I need to do so the judges will see I won.”

And if a fourth bout between the two ring icons pushes through, it won’t come as a surprise if Marquez sports a shirt that says: “I beat Pacquiao thrice.”

Get Inquirer updates while on the go, add us on these apps:

Inquirer Viber

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • Yamanqui

    mama why my pants keep falling down?..- Manny, I told you!! that belt isn’t yours

  • Anonymous

    Marquez used every dirty trick in his arsenal just to beat Pacquiao but sad to say, “No can do, Amigo”. He peppered Manny with low blows, step on the Filipinos foot to keep him outbalanced, but worse of all, he headbutted Pacquiao causing a gash off his brows. Knowing Manny he just focused on the fight and landed more blows to an over cautious buy dirty fighting challenger. The result was clear as day, Manny won it though a much closer decision than the previous two bouts they fought. Pacquiao beat him thrice and as Duran said, “No Mas, No Mas” for a 4th fight. Adios El Mejicano Perderor !!

  • Anonymous

    forget Juan-ma he’s history, he got his chance and blew it, playing safe and waiting for Pacman to come in so he could counter punch wont win championship, he’s the chalenger he’s supposed to be aggressive to go all out and knock out the Pacman, in a close fight the judges sure to favor the aggressive fighter more so if he’s the champion,,, incidentally did you know that KFC known as America’s best chicken now has a new rival its known as MFC Mayweather Fried Chicken.

  • Anonymous

    In answer to Marquez’ query on what you should do to win over Pacquiao, simply win convincingly.  You cannot backpedal all of twelve rounds landing  a few counterpunches and be a winner.  As challenger, you should be aggresive and carry the fight to the champion.  You cannot be too cautious and claim victory, too.  Even in war, the side that advances gains more territory.  The side that retreats shows signs of weakness and cannot be a victor.

  • Anonymous

    PACMAN is the current King of the boxing. Marquez was the challenger. If Marquez wants to claim that he is better than the King, then he should have fough well and knock out or knock down tge king, even for one instanc only. Since, Marquez was not able to knock down or knock out PACMAN, that means he is not better than PACMAN. Manny Pacquaio remains still the best of teh boxer on Earth. For Marquez? He is but a challenger that proves nothing in a three time fight.

  • Anonymous

    natalo si pakyaw kasi hindi siya pinagbigyan ni jinkee…hehehe ayun nag mariang palad si hudas barabas…kinabukasan nanlalambot. muntik tuloy matalo..LOL….

  • Mackoy Matignas

    Manny wants a 4th fight, yes because of this kinds of reaction. Kung mexicano na lang siguro hinayaan niya na eh kaso ultimo kababayan niya may ganyan pa. sa tingin niyo sino nagbibigay ng idea sa kanya? di ba tayo rin. di na lang kasi natin enjoyein yung laban. it was a classic fight ika nga hindi kung anu ano pa pinagsasabi natin

  • Anonymous

    Manny said he wanted the viewer to be satified. He failed and lost in this way. Not because he cant really fight. But because he wanted a 4th match pay check (ano ka? Hilo?). Ano tingin mo sa viewer, naloloko mo lang? 

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


editors' picks



latest videos