Paris Saint-Germain’s French forward Kylian Mbappe (R) is congratulated by Paris Saint-Germain’s Brazilian forward Neymar after scoring a goal during the French Cup semi-final football match between Olympique Lyonnais (OL) and Paris Saint-Germain (PSG) at the Groupama Stadium in Decines-Charpieu, centraleastern France, on March 4, 2020. (Photo by Philippe DESMAZES / AFP)
With football having ground to a halt because of the coronavirus pandemic, the usual transfer rumour mill has fallen silent and nobody cares much where Neymar or Paul Pogba might be playing next season.
Nobody even knows when next season might be, and the financial impact on football clubs, and therefore the transfer market, is likely to be significant.
A study by KPMG this week estimated that cancelling the rest of this season would cost clubs across Europe’s top five leagues as much as four billion euros ($4.33 billion) in lost revenue.
The knock-on effect could be enormous, trickling down to smaller clubs worldwide.
After all, look at a club like Monaco, who have raked in huge sums in recent years from selling players like Kylian Mbappe, who went to Paris Saint-Germain in 2018 for 180 million euros. They have then invested that money in new recruits, helping spread the wealth.
“Given the international situation, clubs are going to be less inclined to pay the kind of sums we look for,” admitted Monaco’s vice-president, Oleg Petrov.
Nevertheless, beyond worrying about who Mbappe, Neymar or Pogba could sign for, there is a more pressing concern.
What about players out of contract?
UEFA’s commitment to ending the European season by June 30 was surely partly because it is common practice for contracts to run until that date.
Players like Manchester City’s David Silva, Willian at Chelsea, or Paris Saint-Germain’s Thiago Silva and Edinson Cavani, will be free to leave on July 1 even if the season has not been completed.
FIFA has set up a working group which could amend rules on transfers and make changes to “protect contracts for both players and clubs”.
However, clubs are already having to take drastic action to stave off financial disaster.
Some French sides, including Lyon, put their players on short-time working as a means of saving money. Swiss outfit Sion cancelled the contracts of nine players who refused to go on temporary unemployment.
In Scotland it is not unusual for player contracts to expire immediately after the scheduled last game of the season in May. In any case, struggling Hearts have asked players and staff to accept 50 percent pay cuts.
Meanwhile, young players who are out of contract are a problem, points out David Venditelli, a French agent whose company Score represents Arsenal’s Alexandre Lacazette among others.
“Things are on hold for these players who are in a precarious position. They are the ones who are the most in danger,” he says.
More free agents might find themselves on the market, but the biggest Champions League stars are unlikely to be impacted.
Changed dynamics?
Super-agents will keep playing the game, like Mino Raiola, whose clients include Pogba and Borussia Dortmund’s Erling Braut Haaland.
Raiola told Spanish sports daily Marca this week that he hoped “to one day transfer a massive player to Real Madrid” and would “try to do it this summer”.
Elsewhere, the dynamics of the market may change. “In some ways people will be eyeing up bargains,” says one agent with in-depth knowledge of the British market. “A distressed club becomes a motivated seller, so there will be a fire sale of a distressed club selling its assets.”
However, the reality is that nothing is happening right now.
“Nobody wants to get involved in that sort of thing now. Our primary job at the moment is to make sure all our staff are looked after,” says Jonathan Barnett, whose clients include Gareth Bale.
“We all have the same problems, with uncertainty and things. We’re not thinking about the summer or transfers because we don’t know how far this thing is going to go.”